Wall Street is No Help in This Bear Market — You Can’t Trust its Advice
November 13th, 2008I shook my head in dismay the other day when General Motors (GM), at a price of $4, was downgraded to Sell by Deutsche Bank and to Underweight by Barclay’s Capital. GM’s stock had been steadily eroding for a long time, from over $42 in October 2007, while the bear market was taking hold and the economy was rolling over.
These opinion shifts are worthless at this point. Where were these analysts over the last year? Actually, Deutsche Bank had a Buy rating on GM until it was altered on February 25 at $24 to a Hold. A Hold is a neutral rating, a hedge, and certainly misleading in this case. Insiders know that a downgrade from Buy to Hold is a highly negative signal, as I point out in my book, Full of Bull, but most individual investors don’t know this code. So on the surface Deutsche Bank was fooling you, communicating advice to hang onto the shares while they nosedived all the way to $4.
Citigroup’s investment ratings on GM were similarly misleading, moving from a Buy to a Hold late last May after the shares had already fallen to under $18, and finally capitulating in early October to a Sell, with the stock below $8. These opinion changes were akin to making a forecast that the Titanic would sink after observing its bow end jutting straight up into the air, minutes away from total submergence. Pathetic. It didn’t take rocket science to realize that the auto industry would tank once oil prices skyrocketed, and consumer spending and the economy started showing signs of collapsing.
Wall Street is bad at stock picking and loathe to admit we are in a roaring bear market. You can’t trust its advice. The best analysts, as ranked in the October Institutional Investor (I.I.) magazine 2008 poll, offered some of the following recommendations over the last year: A leader in covering brokers and asset managers recommended Bear Sterns in January at $77. Eight weeks later it was selling at $2. The No. 1-ranked insurance industry analyst reconfirmed his long-standing Buy opinion on AIG in August and retained his favorable view until the federal seizure at $3 a share in mid-September. The top-rated analyst in consumer finance pounded the table enthusiastically endorsing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac right up until their government takeover below $1 a share.
Street analysts can’t pick stocks (as I emphasize in Full of Bull) because they’re not paid for that skill. It’s like asking an NFL quarterback to make an open field tackle. He’s not trained in that capability, it’s not his job. In its poll published last month, I.I. magazine asked institutional investors, the main client audience for Street analysts, to rank the most important attributes that they desired in equity analysts. At the top was industry knowledge; the lowest ranking priority was stock selection, at No. 12. No wonder Street investment recommendations are so bad. Stock picking is hardly in their job description.
Wall Street, with its eternal optimism, is more in a mode of recommending catching falling safes these days instead of helping you recognize risks and advising protection of capital. My perspective is that it seems we may have lost control over the domestic economy. The next big impact will be the bursting of the consumer credit bubble. I believe this will lead to the worst decline in consumer spending since the Great Depression. Restaurants, retail stores, airlines, auto manufacturers, almost any business that carries considerable debt or that depends heavily on discretionary spending, will be hard-pressed to survive. This will be a long and deep recession. Federal bailout loans are no antidote for the stocks of troubled companies; the shares can still collapse to virtually zero.
So don’t listen to the Street. Avoid risky strategies that involve buying stocks or you’ll get flattened. This is a time to preserve your capital and see how low the economy and the stock market might go over the next 12 months.